Case Studies and Reports
Welcome to NAMLE’s comprehensive resource, with compelling case studies and reports that underscore the effectiveness and significance of media literacy education in early childhood education, K-12 schools and beyond. Through a curated selection of evidence-based research and real-world examples, we aim to highlight the critical role media literacy plays in empowering students, educators, and communities to navigate today’s complex media landscape.
Case Study 2: Media Literacy Education; Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 2024
From the report: There is significant evidence that media literacy training can help people identify false stories and unreliable news sources. However, variation in pedagogical approaches means the effectiveness of one program does not necessarily imply the effectiveness of another. The most successful variants empower motivated individuals to take control of their media consumption and seek out high-quality information—instilling confidence and a sense of responsibility alongside skills development. While media literacy training shows promise, it suffers challenges in speed, scale, and targeting. Reaching large numbers of people, including those most susceptible to disinformation, is expensive and takes many years. Read the full report here.
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, 2023
From the report: Failure to invest in young people’s ability to navigate the complex world of online news and media has consequences for the young people themselves and for society. Media literacy education has the potential to create a more informed consumer, but most programs fall short of their promise because of scarce funding, uneven content, or poorly qualified instructors. The lack of a reference standard for a digital media literacy curriculum adds to the problem. Read the full report here.
Reagan-Udall Foundation of the FDA, 2023
From the report: Strategy 2.2: Collaborate with other agencies, such as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and National Institutes of Health or organizations working to improve consumers’ health and media literacy, as part of a long-term strategy to empower consumers to recognize misleading information on their own. Several of the experts the Foundation interviewed pointed to health and media literacy among consumers as essential to increasing public understanding of FDA-regulated products.
Tactic 2.2.2: Pilot a media literacy education program in partnership with a third-party organization, such as NAMLE or the Media Education Lab, to build and test a curriculum educating youth about how to spot and vet trustworthy information sources. This partnership would fuse the FDA’s extensive scientific knowledge with the organizational infrastructure of a specialized third party to maximize the impact of the pilot. Read the full report here.
Media Education Lab, University of Rhode Island, 2022
From the report: The Media Education Lab has released a new report which documents findings resulting from a statewide study of the level of media literacy integration in RI schools. The study includes an online survey of over 500 school educators, administrators, parents, elected public officials, and community members, along with interviews with 30 respondents who provided more in-depth information. After analyzing the findings, we issue letter grades to school districts in Rhode Island to document their efforts in providing media literacy education to all students. Read the full report here.
DemocracyReady NY, 2021
From the report: To fulfill the state constitutional guarantee of “preparation for civic participation,” schools must equitably prepare all students to understand, critique, and create media, particularly on civic issues. Media literacy—the “ability to access, analyze, evaluate, create, and act using all forms of communication”—must be a high priority in all schools. This report from the DemocracyReady NY Coalition, a nonpartisan, intergenerational statewide partnership, offers recommendations to guide school officials, policymakers, and the public in advancing and improving media literacy education. In keeping with the Coalition’s equity-centered mission, the report confronts systemic issues that stand in the way. Read the full report here.
Technology in Early Childhood Center at Erikson Institute, National Association for Media Literacy Education (NAMLE), Association for Library Service to Children (ALSC), Association of Children’s Museums (ACM), 2021
From the report: Caregivers, practitioners, community and organization leaders, researchers, and policy-influencers all have a stake in impacting young children’s media literacy. All who serve young children hold an opportunity to challenge and overcome barriers which stand in the way of implementing media literacy education.
Current Barriers to Media Literacy in Early Childhood
- Lack of resources and support for practitioners
- Lack of resources and support for caregivers
- Disconnected caregiver-practitioner relationship
- Practitioners not trained or not confident in their media literacy practice
- Lack of support for administration and leadership
- Lack of inclusivity and reach in the media literacy movement
- Lack of policies
- Insufficient funding
- Lack of research
- Low value of media literacy, child development, and early education
National Council of Teachers of English, 2021
From the report: The Task Force on Critical Media Literacy was convened in June, 2020 with a group of academic scholars, longtime NCTE media literacy advocates, and classroom teachers selected by NCTE Executive Director Emily Kirkpatrick, President Leah Zuidema, and the Executive Committee. The Task Force was charged with assessing the current national landscape of policies, practices, resources, and dialogue related to critical media literacy education.
Five Key Recommendations:
- Improve NCTE members’ understanding of Critical Media Literacy
- Help NCTE members integrate Critical Media Literacy into the curriculum
- Increase the visibility of media texts, authors, and pedagogies across the NCTE community
- Energize and inspire the NCTE community by cultivating leadership and advocacy competencies
- Improve public understanding of Critical Media Literacy and promote its relevance to English education, communication, and democracy
RAND Corporation, 2019
From the report: Recommendations for Policymakers, Practitioners, and the Public — Consider the full range of ML competencies. One clear observation that emerged from our analysis is that the ML field pulls from a nuanced body of knowledge, one that was in development well before recent increases in attention to the issues of misinformation and disinformation. As a result, we recommend that practitioners and policymakers turning to ML as a response to these challenges consider not only the narrow aspects of ML that appear immediately relevant (e.g., fact-checking, searching online) but also the full body of evidence that exists about the relationships between individuals and the information ecosystem. Increasing the lines of communication between practitioners and researchers can contribute to this work.
Engage diverse constituencies in scaling ML education. The scaling of ML efforts is both necessary and difficult. One way to scale ML efforts, it seems, might be to use other agents of ML in addition to teachers, and other forums for ML in addition to schools. This might mean enlisting community members—pastors or rabbis, librarians, parents, or professional mentors can serve as agents of ML in both formal and informal ways. Although we need more research on what works when it comes to improving ML, pursuing this decentralized approach to ML education might be one way to achieve the “herd immunity” that the experts we interviewed pointed toward. We note that although this recommendation is aimed first at policymakers and practitioners, it is also a recommendation with important implications for the general public. If scaling ML relies on the grassroots efforts of individuals, then parents, coaches, bosses, mentors, and friends could play an important and central role in expanding the reach and success of ML education. Read the full report here.

Social Media and Adolescent Health